Home›Insurance›My insurer relies on the faulty…
Insurance law
My insurer relies on the faulty workmanship exclusion: is everything excluded?
A badly soldered joint, a poorly installed membrane, a drain laid wrong: the insurer says faulty workmanship and closes the file. The clause often says something else.
Updated 15 November 2026
The short answer
Often, the faulty workmanship exclusion has two parts: the insurer does not cover the cost of correcting the defective work, but it does cover damage to property caused by an insured peril resulting from that defect. The Supreme Court of Canada read a similar clause, in a builders' risk policy, as excluding only the cost of redoing the faulty work (Ledcor, 2016 SCC 37). In Quebec, an exclusion must be stipulated expressly and restrictively (article 2464), and, where the policy is a contract of adhesion, any doubt is resolved in favour of the insured (article 1432).
Two sentences, two rules
The clause often reads roughly like this: the insurer does not cover the cost of correcting faulty design, material or workmanship; it does, however, cover damage caused directly to property by an insured peril resulting from that faulty design, material or workmanship.
The first sentence excludes. The second, sometimes called the exception to the exclusion, brings the damage that flows from the defect back into coverage. A denial that quotes only the first sentence reports only half the clause.
A common example: a badly soldered plumbing joint gives way and water spreads under the floor. Redoing the joint falls within the exclusion. The water that damaged the floor, the walls and the contents is the resulting damage.
What the Supreme Court decided
In Ledcor, decided in 2016, the Supreme Court of Canada considered a faulty workmanship exclusion in builders' risk policies. Window cleaners had scratched the windows of a tower under construction, and the windows had to be replaced. The clause excluded the cost of making good faulty workmanship, except resulting physical damage "not otherwise excluded".
The Court held that the clause excluded only the cost of redoing the faulty work, that is, cleaning the windows again. The cost of replacing the windows was covered (paragraph 5).
The case came from Alberta, a common law province, and concerned builders' risk insurance. In Quebec, a policy is interpreted under the Civil Code: the decision is a guide by analogy, not a rule that applies as is to every homeowner policy.
The Civil Code rules
A damage insurer must make good the loss caused by superior force or by the fault of the insured, unless an exclusion is expressly and restrictively stipulated in the contract (article 2464). An exclusion does not reach beyond its terms.
An insurance policy is usually a contract of adhesion: its essential stipulations were drafted by the insurer and could not be freely negotiated (article 1379). In case of doubt, the contract is interpreted in favour of the adhering party (article 1432).
Clauses are also interpreted by one another, each being given the meaning derived from the contract as a whole (article 1427). A reading of the exclusion that would deprive the exception in the same clause of any effect is hard to defend.
Who has to prove what
A person seeking to enforce a right must prove the facts on which the claim rests, and a person alleging that a right is extinguished or modified must prove the facts on which that allegation rests (article 2803).
In practice, the insured first establishes that the loss falls within the coverage. The insurer must then show that the exclusion applies. It is then for the insured to show that the damage claimed falls within the exception (Ledcor, paragraph 52): that is often where the file is decided.
That debate is settled with an expert report that identifies the cause and separates the costs. A quote that distinguishes correcting the defect from repairing the resulting damage is worth far more than a single lump sum.
Faulty workmanship, wear and inherent vice
Insurers sometimes rely at the same time on wear and tear, gradual deterioration or the inherent vice of the property. The Civil Code itself provides that the insurer is not bound to indemnify losses that result from the inherent vice of the property or its nature (article 2465).
Those grounds are not necessarily the same as faulty workmanship. Each must be tied to a specific clause or, for inherent vice, to article 2465, and to proven facts. See denied water damage claims.
The excluded cost is not always lost
What the insurer does not pay, correcting the defective work, can sometimes be claimed from the contractor who did it. A contractor must act in accordance with the usual practices and rules of the trade (article 2100). For immovable works, the contractor warrants the work for one year against poor workmanship existing at acceptance or discovered within the following year (article 2120), and is liable for the loss of the work occurring within five years after the work is completed (article 2118).
Those remedies have their own conditions and their own deadlines. For example, a client who accepts the work without reservation keeps a remedy only for defects or poor workmanship that were not apparent (article 2113). They are prepared at the same time as the insurance claim, not afterwards.
Get the full policy wording
The renewal package, with the coverage summary and endorsements, does not always contain the full text of the exclusions. Ask the insurer for the complete wording of the policy in force on the date of loss.
Until the clause has been read in full, the argument rests on how the adjuster summarized it in an email. That is a weak foundation, for you and for the insurer.
What to gather
- The complete wording of the policy in force on the date of loss
- The denial letter and the exclusion clause it quotes
- The insurer's adjuster or expert report
- A quote that separates correcting the defect from repairing the damage
- The contract and invoices of the contractor who did the work
- The defective part, if it could be kept, and photos
A denial based on faulty workmanship?
A free 15-minute phone consultation to review the clause relied on and what it leaves within the coverage.
This page is general information and does not constitute legal advice.