Home›Insurance›Mortgage life insurance: why is the…

Insurance law

Mortgage life insurance: why is the insurer paying only part of the balance?

The family believed the loan was fully insured. The settlement letter announces a percentage. You need to understand where it comes from before challenging it.

Updated 15 November 2026

The short answer

Loan insurance offered by the lender does not always cover the whole balance. A percentage may have been set when the borrower enrolled, and an increase or refinancing may not have been insured if a new application was not submitted or accepted. Ask for the calculation in writing and for copies of the signed applications. If premiums were taken in error for coverage that did not exist, they should, as a rule, be restored (article 1491). In life insurance, the insurer must pay within 30 days of receiving the required proof (article 2436).

How loan insurance works

Loan insurance is usually group insurance, which covers, under a master policy, the persons who belong to a defined group (article 2392): here, the lender's borrowers, who enrol when the loan is made. When the insured dies, the insurer generally pays the sum insured to the lender, which applies it to the loan balance.

What is covered depends on the signed enrolment application and on the insurer's decision on it. That is not always what the loan statements show.

The usual reasons for a partial payment

A percentage chosen at enrolment. When two borrowers are insured, each may be insured for a share of the loan. The application then generally states a percentage, and that percentage applies.

An increase that was never insured. On a refinancing or an increase, the new portion may require a new application and a new risk assessment. If none was submitted or accepted, only the balance already insured generally remains covered, and it is then expressed as a percentage of the new loan.

A disputed declaration. Misrepresentation or concealment of the risk can lead to the contract being annulled (article 2410). In the absence of fraud, however, it cannot ground the annulment or reduction of insurance that has been in force for two years (article 2424). Where coverage was added through successive refinancings, the effective date of each must be checked.

Ask for the calculation and the documents

Ask in writing for the detail of the calculation: insured balance, percentage, effective date of each coverage, and the document the insurer relies on. Also ask for copies of the signed applications, the acceptance letters and the medical questionnaires.

One detail can change everything: an application that states no percentage, or an acceptance letter saying that where none is indicated, the insurance covers the full amount. The file is read from the documents, not from the settlement letter's summary of them.

The information the insurer and the lender hold about the insured can be requested. See how to get a copy of your file from the insurer.

Premiums paid for nothing

Sometimes the premium was calculated on the full loan for years, while the insurer now says only part of it was insured. If the insurer is right, the premium for the uninsured part was paid for nothing in return.

A payment made in error obliges the person who received it to restore it (article 1491). The amount owed bears interest from the time of default (article 1617), and an additional indemnity may be added (article 1619). A refund offered without interest, or calculated over too short a period, should be checked. The three-year limitation period may, however, limit the period that can be recovered (article 2925).

The lender's role

The insurance was often offered when the loan or refinancing was arranged, by the person preparing the financing file. What the borrower understood about the coverage comes from that meeting.

A lender that offers the insurance itself generally acts as a distributor. The person distributing it must then describe the product, state the nature of the coverage and clearly point out the exclusions (section 431 of the Act respecting the distribution of financial products and services). If the borrower did not receive that information, the distributor is liable for the resulting injury, and the insurer may also be liable in some cases (section 436 of the same Act).

Good faith must govern the conduct of the parties, both when the obligation arises and when it is performed (article 1375). A lender that keeps collecting a full premium and showing full coverage, while part of the loan is not insured, may have its own liability examined, separately from the insurer's.

It must still be established who decided not to insure the increase, and what the borrower knew. That is what the document requests are for.

Deadlines

The insurer must pay the sums insured within 30 days of receiving the proof required for payment (article 2436). The deadline is 60 days for sickness or accident insurance, unless it covers loss of income due to disability.

A claim against the insurer or the lender generally prescribes after three years (article 2925). A pending complaint should not make you lose sight of that deadline. See how to complain about your insurer.

What to gather

  • The settlement letter and the detail of the calculation
  • The signed enrolment applications and the insurer's acceptance letters
  • The loan and refinancing deeds
  • Statements showing the premium charged, year by year
  • The death certificate and the estate documents
  • The insurer's and the lender's answers to your complaints

See all insurance matters

Loan insurance paid only in part?

A free 15-minute phone consultation to review the settlement letter and the documents to obtain.

This page is general information and does not constitute legal advice.