The short answer
Business interruption insurance indemnifies the drop in income caused by a covered loss, during an indemnity period defined by the policy. It generally depends on the physical damage being covered: until the cause is accepted as covered, the insurer is reluctant to pay. The calculation rests on your figures: financial statements, monthly sales, continuing expenses. Provide them early, because the 60-day payment deadline runs from receipt of the information and documents requested (article 2473), and document your efforts to resume operations: the policy often requires it, and the party responsible for the loss is not liable for any aggravation you could have avoided (article 1479).
What this coverage is for
A loss does not only cost repairs. While the premises or equipment are out of use, sales stop while rent, wages and loans keep running.
Business interruption coverage, also called business income or loss of earnings coverage, addresses that loss. Its scope depends entirely on the policy wording: gross profit, revenue, extra expenses incurred to shorten the shutdown, sometimes the cost of a temporary set-up.
It generally requires covered physical damage. Depending on the policy wording, if the cause of the damage is excluded, the business interruption may be excluded too. That is why the debate over the cause of the loss often decides both parts of the claim at once.
The indemnity period
The policy sets a maximum length and, often, a definition: the period during which the business's results are affected by the loss, or the time reasonably needed to repair and resume operations.
The disagreement often concerns the end date. The insurer sometimes sets it when it paid for the equipment; the insured places it when the business could actually resume. Insist that the date chosen be tied in writing to a clause of the policy.
If the restart was delayed by waiting for an expert report or a payment, that chronology must be documented, date by date.
The evidence is accounting evidence
The indemnity is calculated from your results: sales in comparable months, the trend before the loss, continuing expenses and expenses saved. The clearer your figures, the less room there is for an unfavourable estimate.
Gather the financial statements for recent years, monthly sales, sales tax returns and invoices for fixed costs. An accountant who knows the business is often the best counterpart for the insurer's expert.
When the insurer proposes a calculation, ask for the method and the data used. A nil or very low result is often explained by the comparison period chosen or by an expense treated as saved.
The insurer's deadlines
At the insurer's request, the insured must disclose the circumstances of the loss and provide supporting documents (article 2471). The insurer must then pay the indemnity within 60 days of receiving the notice of loss or, if it asked for them, the relevant information and supporting documents (article 2473).
That deadline is a tool: send the business interruption documents in writing, all at once if possible, and note the date. A request for documents that keeps coming back becomes part of the record in its own right.
Nothing prevents you from asking in writing for an advance on the part of the claim that is not disputed. A business that is shut can lose its premises or its customers before the file is settled.
The duty to limit the loss
A person bound to make reparation for an injury is not liable for any aggravation of that injury which the victim could have avoided (article 1479). Policies often say the same: resume operations as soon as possible, look for temporary equipment or premises.
Document every step: rental quotes, searches for premises, exchanges with suppliers. If the insurer asked you to put a step on hold pending its expert report, keep that instruction in writing.
The party responsible for the loss
When the damage comes from the leased building, for example a pipe that gives way, the landlord may be liable. A lessor must deliver the property in a good state of repair, provide peaceable enjoyment and make all necessary repairs during the lease, except minor maintenance repairs (articles 1854 and 1864).
A commercial lease may, however, contain insurance or waiver clauses that must be read before acting. The insurer that indemnified you is subrogated to your rights for what it paid (article 2474); the deductible and the uninsured loss remain yours to claim. A waiver of your recourse against the landlord may also prevent the insurer from being subrogated; it may then be released, in whole or in part, from its obligation to you (article 2474). The claim generally prescribes after three years (article 2925).
What to gather
- The full policy, with the business interruption section and its definitions
- Financial statements for recent years and monthly sales
- Invoices for continuing expenses: rent, wages, loans
- The insurer's document requests and what you sent, dated
- Proof of your efforts to resume operations
- The commercial lease, if the loss came from the building
A business shut down by a loss?
A free 15-minute phone consultation to review the insurer's calculation and the period it used.
This page is general information and does not constitute legal advice.