Home›Insurance›Replacement cost: can my insurer hold…

Insurance law

Replacement cost: can my insurer hold back part of the indemnity?

The cheque arrives, but it is lower than expected. The difference is not always lost: it is often held back, on conditions.

Updated 15 November 2026

The short answer

Replacement cost coverage is a special valuation formula set by the contract (article 2490). It generally comes with conditions: the insurer first pays the actual cash value, after depreciation, and pays the difference only once the property has been repaired or replaced, often within a deadline set by the policy. Read that deadline as soon as the first payment arrives, keep every replacement invoice, and challenge in writing any depreciation rate that is not justified.

Two ways to value a loss

Damage insurance obliges the insurer to make good the loss suffered at the time of the loss, but only up to the amount of insurance (article 2463). When the contract does not provide a special valuation formula, the value of the property is established in the usual manner (article 2490): in practice, its value on the day of the loss, which accounts for age and wear.

Replacement cost coverage is exactly such a special formula. It indemnifies the cost of repairing or replacing with new property of the same kind and quality, with no deduction for depreciation.

The gap between the two can be large: ten-year-old equipment, a roof, appliances, a full set of furniture.

The holdback until replacement

Often, the policy does not pay replacement cost in one go. The insurer first pays the depreciated value, then the difference once the property has actually been repaired or replaced. That difference is the holdback.

Conditions vary from one policy to another: a deadline to replace, replacement with similar property, sometimes rebuilding on the same site. The policy, not a general rule, sets them. Ask the adjuster for them in writing, with the exact amount held back.

If you decide not to replace, the policy generally provides that you keep the indemnity already paid, but give up the holdback.

The replacement deadline

This is often where money is lost. The deadline keeps running while the insured is waiting for an expert, a contractor, a supplier or new premises.

If you cannot replace within the deadline, write to the insurer before it expires, explain why and ask for an extension. Keep the answer.

An insurer whose own delays held up the settlement is in a difficult position to blame the insured afterwards for not replacing in time. Good faith must govern the conduct of the parties, both when the obligation arises and when it is performed (article 1375).

Challenging the depreciation rate

Depreciation is not a fixed percentage. It depends on the age of the property, its useful life, its condition and its maintenance. Ask the insurer how it calculated it, item by item.

Well-maintained equipment, recently serviced or still under warranty, depreciates less than neglected property. Maintenance invoices, photos taken before the loss and proof of purchase are directly useful here.

If the amount of insurance is too low

An insurer may not refuse to cover the risk solely because the amount of insurance is lower than the value of the property. In that case, however, it is released by paying a proportional indemnity if the loss is partial (article 2493).

In other words, underinsurance can reduce the indemnity even when the loss is fully covered. Check the amount of insurance at every renewal, especially after renovations or the purchase of equipment.

What the insurer does not pay can be claimed elsewhere

The deductible and the depreciation you do not recover remain yours as far as your insurer is concerned. They are not necessarily yours as far as the person responsible for the loss is concerned: an owner who did not maintain the plumbing, a contractor, a neighbour.

The insurer that indemnifies you is subrogated to your rights against the person who caused the loss, up to the amount it paid (article 2474). If, through your own act, it can no longer be subrogated, for example because you gave the responsible person a release, it may be released in whole or in part from its obligation to you. The rest of your loss remains yours to claim. It is worth coordinating your claim with the insurer's rather than each acting alone.

What to gather

  • The policy, especially the replacement cost clause and its conditions
  • The settlement letter with the depreciation breakdown
  • The amount held back and the replacement deadline, confirmed in writing
  • Proof of purchase, maintenance invoices and photos taken before the loss
  • Replacement quotes and invoices
  • Any request for an extension and the insurer's reply

See all insurance matters

A holdback or depreciation you dispute?

A free 15-minute phone consultation to check the insurer's calculation and the time you have left.

This page is general information and does not constitute legal advice.