Home›Civil law›Manufacturer's warranty expired: does…

Civil and commercial law

Manufacturer's warranty expired: does the dealer still have to repair?

The engine, the transmission or the battery fails a few months after the warranty ends. The dealer says the warranty is over. That is only one of the two warranties.

Updated 15 November 2026

The short answer

The manufacturer's warranty is a conventional warranty that adds to the legal warranty without replacing it: the Consumer Protection Act cannot be derogated from by private agreement (section 261). The Act requires goods to be durable in normal use for a reasonable length of time, having regard to their price, the terms of the contract and the conditions of their use (section 38). That claim can be brought directly against the merchant or the manufacturer (section 54), and a subsequent purchaser keeps a claim against the manufacturer.

Two warranties, two lengths

The manufacturer's warranty has a precise length, in years and kilometres. It is written and ends on the stated date, but its term is extended by the time the merchant or manufacturer had the car to perform it or following a recall (section 50).

The legal warranty has no fixed end date. Goods forming the object of a contract must be fit for the purpose for which goods of that kind are ordinarily used (section 37), and durable in normal use for a reasonable length of time, having regard to their price, the terms of the contract and the conditions of their use (section 38).

The Act allows the merchant or the manufacturer to offer a warranty more advantageous than the one it provides (section 35). The reverse is not possible: the Act cannot be derogated from by private agreement (section 261), and the consumer cannot waive a right it confers (section 262).

What is a reasonable length of time?

The Act gives no figure. The court considers the price paid, the terms of the contract and the conditions of use of the car (section 38), which can include its class and how it was maintained.

A transmission that fails on a well-maintained car is not assessed like a wear part. Recalls and technical service bulletins covering the same component on the same model are often useful.

The maintenance record is decisive here. The merchant or manufacturer cannot require you to prove that previous owners complied with the warranty conditions (section 52.1), but your own maintenance will be examined.

Who to claim against

A consumer who contracted with a merchant may bring a claim based on sections 37, 38 or 39 directly against the merchant or the manufacturer (section 54). The same applies to a latent defect you could not have detected by an ordinary examination, and neither can plead that it was unaware of the defect (section 53).

A subsequent purchaser, who bought the car used, keeps a claim against the manufacturer (sections 53 and 54).

The Civil Code also makes the manufacturer and distributors bound by the seller's warranty (article 1730), and presumes the defect existed when property sold by a professional seller deteriorates prematurely compared with identical property or property of the same type (article 1729). See the defective vehicle.

What you can ask for

If the merchant or manufacturer fails to fulfil an obligation imposed by the Act, the consumer may demand, as the case may be, performance of the obligation, authorization to have it performed at their expense, a reduction of the consumer's obligation, or the cancellation or annulment of the contract, without prejudice to a claim for damages. Punitive damages may also be claimed (section 272).

In practice, for a repair needed after the warranty, the most common request is reimbursement of the repair cost, or a price reduction.

Before you pay for the repair

Notify the merchant and the manufacturer in writing before having the car repaired, unless it is urgent. Describe the problem and give them a chance to examine the car. For a latent defect, the buyer must give written notice within a reasonable time after discovering it (article 1739 of the Civil Code).

If you must have it repaired to keep driving, choose a garage that documents its diagnosis, keep the replaced parts and photograph them.

The manufacturer must give the owner or their representative access to the car's data for diagnosis, maintenance or repair (section 39.4). An independent garage can therefore make its own diagnosis.

The extended warranty sold at the counter

Before offering you a paid additional warranty, the merchant must tell you orally and in writing about the existence and content of the legal warranty under sections 37 and 38 and, where applicable, tell you orally about the existence and length of the manufacturer's free warranty (section 228.1). A merchant who fails to do so is deemed to have failed to mention an important fact.

An extended warranty can be useful, but it does not replace the legal warranty. Its exclusions must be clearly set out in separate and successive clauses (section 44).

Used cars bought from a dealer

The sale of a used car by a merchant carries a warranty of good working order based on its class: six months or 10,000 kilometres for class A, three months or 5,000 kilometres for class B, one month or 1,700 kilometres for class C (sections 159 and 160). Class D has no warranty of good working order, but the general warranties of sections 37 and 38 apply to every class.

The claim generally prescribes after three years (article 2925 of the Civil Code). Where the injury appears gradually, the period runs from the day it first appears (article 2926).

What to gather

  • The purchase or lease contract
  • The manufacturer's warranty and, if any, the extended warranty
  • The maintenance record and invoices
  • The diagnosis and the repair quote
  • Your written notices to the dealer and the manufacturer, and their replies
  • Recalls or technical bulletins covering the component

See all civil and commercial matters

A repair refused after the warranty?

A free 15-minute phone consultation to see whether the legal warranty still covers the defect.

This page is general information and does not constitute legal advice.