Home›Civil law›My new car keeps going back to the…
Civil and commercial law
My new car keeps going back to the dealer: is it a lemon?
The car is a few months old. It is going back to the dealer for the third time, for the same problem. The law now gives a precise answer to that situation.
Updated 15 November 2026
The short answer
Section 53.1 of the Consumer Protection Act allows the court to declare a car a seriously defective automobile (« automobile gravement défectueuse » in the French text) when, under the manufacturer's basic warranty, it has had three unsuccessful repair attempts for the same defect, one or two attempts while it stayed at the dealer for more than 30 days, or 12 attempts for unrelated defects. The defects must have appeared within three years of the first sale or lease and before 60,000 kilometres, and must make the car unfit for its normal use or substantially reduce its usefulness. A latent defect is then deemed to exist, which opens the way to annulment of the sale, a price reduction and damages.
The conditions of section 53.1
The application belongs to the consumer who owns the car or leases it long term. The court makes the declaration when three conditions are met.
Repairs under the manufacturer's basic warranty. One of the following is required: three unsuccessful attempts for the same defect; one or two unsuccessful attempts for the same defect, where the merchant or manufacturer had the car in its possession for more than 30 days; or 12 attempts for unrelated defects.
A time and mileage limit. The defects must have appeared within three years of the car's first sale or long-term lease to a party other than a dealer authorized by the manufacturer, while it had not travelled more than 60,000 kilometres.
Sufficient seriousness. The defects must make the car unfit for the use for which it is normally intended, or substantially reduce its usefulness.
Counting the 30 days
The days counted are those on which the merchant or manufacturer had the car in its possession, and the work orders serve to prove them. Days are excluded where the merchant or manufacturer shows both that it could not make the repair because of a parts shortage and that it provided a replacement car free of charge.
A parts shortage alone therefore does not stop the count. Note the dates in and out, and keep proof of any replacement car provided, or refused.
What the declaration changes
A seriously defective automobile is deemed to be affected by a latent defect. You no longer have to prove the defect through a battle of experts: the law takes it as established.
The consumer can sue the merchant or the manufacturer directly (section 53) and ask, as the case may be, for annulment or cancellation of the contract or a reduction of the price, in addition to damages, including punitive damages (section 272).
The status follows the vehicle. A merchant offering a used car that has been declared seriously defective must say so on the label (sections 155 and 156), and no one may advertise it without disclosing that fact (section 237.1).
The work orders are the evidence
The file is built visit by visit. For each one, you need a work order showing the date in, the date out, the mileage and the problem described as you reported it.
Ask for a work order even when the technician "found nothing". A visit with no document is a repair attempt that is hard to count.
Describe the symptom the same way at every visit. Three different descriptions of the same noise easily become three different problems.
The manufacturer must also give the owner, the long-term lessee or their representative access to the car's data for diagnosis, maintenance or repair (section 39.4). An independent expert can use it.
Outside those conditions, the legal warranty remains
A car past three years or 60,000 kilometres, or whose visits fall just short of the thresholds, is not left without protection. Goods must be fit for the purpose for which they are ordinarily used, and durable in normal use for a reasonable length of time (sections 37 and 38).
The difference is the evidence: without a declaration, the defect has to be proven. See the legal warranty after the manufacturer's warranty ends.
Electric vehicles, motorhomes and trailers
The Act defines an automobile as a vehicle propelled by any power other than muscular force and adapted for transportation on public highways, other than a moped, a motorized bicycle or a motorcycle. An electric vehicle or a motorized motorhome falls within that definition.
A travel trailer has no engine of its own. It does not appear to be covered by section 53.1, but the Act's general warranties apply to it as to any goods sold by a merchant (sections 37, 38 and 53).
Negotiate, arbitrate or go to court
A formal notice that sets out the count of visits, with the work orders attached, settles a share of these files. See the formal notice.
The Canadian Motor Vehicle Arbitration Plan (CAMVAP) also offers a route for certain disputes with a manufacturer. Its conditions and effects should be checked before you join it, since the arbitrator's decision is final and binding.
What to gather
- The sale or lease contract and the manufacturer's warranty
- Every work order, with dates in and out and the mileage
- Your emails and complaints to the dealer and the manufacturer
- Proof of any replacement car provided or refused
- Recall notices and technical service bulletins for the model
- Costs caused by the car being off the road: rental, transport, towing
A new car that keeps going back to the dealer?
A free 15-minute phone consultation to count the visits and see whether the conditions are met.
This page is general information and does not constitute legal advice.