Home›Real estate›Water damage in a condo: who pays the…
Real estate law
Water damage in a condo: who pays the deductible?
A water heater fails, three units are damaged, and the syndicate sends the deductible invoice to the owner of the unit where the water came from. That is not automatic.
Updated 15 November 2026
The short answer
The syndicate must insure the whole building, including the private portions, with a reasonable deductible (article 1073), and set up a self-insurance fund to pay its deductibles (article 1071.1). The amounts it pays for the deductible can be recovered from co-owners only through their contribution to common expenses, subject to damages owed by a co-owner liable for injury caused by their fault, or in the other cases of liability provided in the Code (article 1074.2). A contrary clause in the declaration is deemed not written.
The syndicate's insurance covers the whole building
The syndicate has an insurable interest in the whole building, including the private portions. It must take out insurance against ordinary risks covering the entire building, excluding improvements made by a co-owner to their portion where they can be identified (article 1073).
The amount insured must allow the building to be rebuilt, and it must be assessed at least every five years by a member of a professional order designated by regulation. The deductible must be reasonable.
Where the syndicate and a co-owner have separately insured the same property against the same risks, the syndicate's insurance is primary (article 1074.3).
The deductible is paid first from the self-insurance fund
The syndicate must set up a self-insurance fund, liquid and available on short notice, used to pay the deductibles under its insurance (article 1071.1). Contributions to that fund are part of the common expenses fixed each year (article 1072).
In other words, the deductible is first an expense of the co-owners as a body, paid by everyone according to their share.
When can the syndicate claim it from a co-owner?
Amounts paid by the syndicate for deductibles and for repairing damage to property in which it has an insurable interest cannot be recovered from co-owners other than through their contribution to common expenses (article 1074.2).
The exception covers damages the syndicate may obtain from a co-owner liable for injury caused by their fault and, in the cases provided in the Code, injury caused by the act or fault of another person or by property in their custody.
Where the water came from is not enough on its own. The fact that the leak started in your unit does not automatically make you liable for the deductible: the syndicate must establish liability. However, if the damage results from the autonomous act of a thing in your custody, such as a water heater that bursts, your fault is presumed and it is up to you to prove you committed none (article 1465). A stipulation in the declaration that departs from article 1074.2 is deemed not written.
Fault, maintenance and property in your custody
A neglected appliance, a water heater kept long past its useful life, work done without respecting the rules of the trade: these are the situations where a co-owner's liability is really in issue.
Conversely, if the water came from a common portion, the syndicate is liable for damage caused to co-owners by a defect in design or construction or by lack of maintenance of the common portions (article 1077).
Either way, the cause is proven by an expert report, not just by where the leak was found.
What your own insurance should cover
The Code provides that each co-owner must take out insurance covering their civil liability towards third parties, for a minimum amount set by regulation (article 1064.1).
The syndicate's insurance does not cover the improvements you made to your private portion, or your belongings. Your policy must cover them, and some policies also offer protection for the syndicate's deductible that might be claimed from you. Check both points at your next renewal.
To tell the original unit apart from improvements, the syndicate's register must contain a description of the private portions precise enough for improvements made by co-owners to be identified (article 1070). Ask for a copy.
If the syndicate does not claim from its insurer
The syndicate may decide not to use its insurance, for example when the damage is close to the deductible. It must then see to the repairs diligently, and it cannot sue a co-owner for damage it would otherwise have been indemnified for under that insurance (article 1074.1).
Also, a co-owner's breach of a condition of the insurance contract cannot be set up against the syndicate (article 1074).
First steps after water damage
Notify the syndicate or the manager immediately, as well as your own insurer. Take photos, note the times, and keep the appliance or part involved.
If a deductible invoice is sent to you, ask in writing what the syndicate bases your liability on, and for a copy of the expert report. See disputes with your co-ownership syndicate.
What to gather
- The declaration of co-ownership and the by-laws
- The syndicate's insurance policy, with its deductible
- Your own policy, including any cover for the syndicate's deductible
- The expert report on the cause of the damage
- The syndicate's invoice or claim notice
- Photos, maintenance invoices and the age of the appliances involved
A deductible claimed by your syndicate?
A free 15-minute phone consultation to check whether the syndicate can claim it from you.
This page is general information and does not constitute legal advice.