Home›Real estate›Duplex or triplex held in…

Real estate law

Duplex or triplex held in co-ownership: who pays for the French drain and foundations?

The neighbours split the bill as if they owned semi-detached houses. Often, though, the building is in divided co-ownership, and the rules are different.

Updated 15 November 2026

The short answer

If a declaration of co-ownership has been registered, a syndicate has existed since registration, even if no one ever ran it (article 1039). The ground, the main structure and the pipes are presumed to be common portions (article 1044), and the declaration often says so. The work is therefore the syndicate's business, and each owner contributes in proportion to the relative value of their fraction (article 1064), not necessarily in equal shares.

First, check how the building is held

Many duplexes and triplexes are divided co-ownerships: each dwelling is a separate fraction, and a declaration of co-ownership has been registered (article 1038). Others are held in undivided co-ownership, or are separate houses sharing a wall.

The answer is in the land register and in the deed of sale. Until the regime is established, any cost split rests on an assumption.

The syndicate exists, even if inactive

From the registration of the declaration, the co-owners as a body constitute a legal person called the syndicate. Its objects include preserving the building and maintaining the common portions, and it must see to it that the necessary work is carried out (article 1039).

In a small co-ownership, it happens that no meeting has ever been held, no fund has been set up and each owner insured "their" part separately. The syndicate exists anyway, with its obligations: contingency fund (article 1071), self-insurance fund (article 1071.1), insurance on the whole building (article 1073), the co-ownership register (article 1070).

The first step in a foundation file is often to get that syndicate working again.

Foundations and drain: common portions

The ground, the main structure of the buildings, common equipment and pipes, including those running through private portions, are presumed to be common portions (article 1044). The declaration of co-ownership usually specifies what is common and sets the boundaries of each private portion.

The French drain, the footing and the foundation wall are therefore, as a rule, common portions. The work is the syndicate's, not a private arrangement between neighbours.

The text of the declaration prevails over the presumption: it must be read, especially the description of the common portions and of the restricted common portions.

The split: relative value, not equal shares

Each co-owner contributes to common expenses in proportion to the relative value of their fraction (article 1064). That value is set in the declaration, based on the nature, destination, dimensions and location of each private portion (article 1041).

In a triplex, the split is rarely one third each. A claim calculated in equal shares, when the declaration provides other percentages, is wrong from the start.

Exception: co-owners who use restricted common portions alone bear the costs of their maintenance and ordinary repairs, and the declaration may provide a different split for major repairs to and replacement of those portions (article 1064).

Decide the work at a meeting

Syndicate decisions are taken by a majority of the votes of the co-owners present or represented (article 1096), each having a number of votes proportional to the relative value of their fraction (article 1090). Work to alter, enlarge or improve the common portions requires three quarters of the votes of the co-owners present or represented, and the same majority decides how their cost is split (article 1097).

One rule protects small co-ownerships: where there are fewer than five fractions, a co-owner with more than half of all votes has their votes reduced to the total votes of the other co-owners present or represented (article 1091).

A co-owner who has work done alone on a common portion, then claims a share from the others, invites a challenge: the expense was neither decided by the syndicate nor split according to the declaration. A resolution, quotes and a calculation that follows the declaration avoid that debate.

Insurance on the building

The syndicate must take out insurance against ordinary risks covering the entire building, including the private portions, but excluding improvements made by a co-owner to their portion where they can be identified from the description of that portion (article 1073).

Some policies exclude water seeping in through the foundations. However, an exclusion of a risk prescribed by regulation must be stated expressly and conspicuously (article 1073). A denial based on such a clause should be checked, but the complete policy must be obtained before reaching a conclusion. See denied water damage claims.

The new co-owner

A person who acquires a fraction must pay, with interest, the common expenses owing on it at the time of acquisition (article 1069). Before buying, they can ask the syndicate for a statement of the common expenses owing. They are then liable for those charges only if the statement is provided within 15 days of the request.

A buyer entering a small co-ownership where foundation work is being discussed should read the declaration, the minutes and the correspondence about that work before signing.

Some declarations provide that disputes go to arbitration. Before any proceeding, that clause must be read and its reach between co-owners checked.

What to gather

  • The registered declaration of co-ownership, with the table of relative values
  • The index of immovables or the deeds of sale, to know which fraction belongs to whom
  • Minutes of meetings, if any
  • The expert report on the foundations and the quotes
  • The building's insurance policy and any denial letter
  • Exchanges between co-owners about the work

See all real estate matters

Foundation work to share?

A free 15-minute phone consultation to check how the building is held and the split it provides for.

This page is general information and does not constitute legal advice.